Tex - had to do the same thing for all three compartments and the missing bow rider insert on my 07 Avalanche C4. Ended up using 3/4" HDPE. It was expensive, but I know it's not going anywhere and you can work it like wood. I used a jigsaw, router, and orbital sander to make mine. If yours have deteriorated to where you can't trace them, I would suggest using cardboard to make a template. Don't forget to allow space around the edges for the upholstery to wrap around. Also, there is about an 1/8" "notch" along the piano hinge. I can try to dig up some pictures of mine if that will help.